McKee’s Book is Poison
I stopped reading Robert McGee’s book “Story” because I think it is an absolutely poisonous book.
I stopped reading after torturing myself day after day trying to finish it.
I stopped reading to save myself, because if there is one sure way to banish all creativity in your writing it is to read this book.
For one thing, the book constantly uses Jaws, Chinatown and Casblanca as the most relevant examples of all his theories - all movies written and directed by precursors of his so-called non-method.
Now understand, I do agree with some of his observations (and yes this is a book about his observations on film), but I draw the line when there pages of illustrated examples (complete with arrows) pointing out the dichotomies of Truth and Lies and oh yes the Contrariness of White Lies to Truth. If this is something you need an illustrated lesson on, I say there are greater obstacles to overcome in your writing.
There is a list of genres which I will say is useful. If you want a copy of this list, save your money I will gladly oblige.
My opinion may not hold as much weight compared to a professional but I will say this - Mr. McKee’s writing credits to date include three TV shows: The Bible, Abraham; J’Accuse Citizen Kane (documentary); Mrs. Columbo.
His pupils include those who have written, directed or produced (does not say which) these movies: Air Force One, Ally McBeal, Crimson Tide, but maddeningly, The Deer Hunter, The Elephant Man, Gandhi, Glory, Leaving Las Vegas, The Truman Show but the list is long as it is varied.
So take it or leave it. You know what I’m going to do.
